Contentious Scores with Halliday

  1. Contentious Scores with Halliday
    By Contentious Character News
    01 September Contentious Scores with Halliday

    A fellow vigneron and old friend of mine, who happens to be French, once arrogantly said to me: ‘Wine Awards are like hemorrhoids, sooner or later everyone gets one’.

    I never thought much of it until we signed the papers to buy Lambert Vineyards and launched Contentious Character. Since then I’ve noticed many wineries cover their bottles in stickers pronouncing they’ve won this or that gold, silver or bronze. Then the emails started coming in with invitations.
    Invitations to enter international shows, national shows, state shows, city shows like the Sydney Royal Wine show, regional shows, small vigneron shows, cool climate shows, fortified wine shows, gender shows like the Australian Wine Women of the Year and the Young Gun of Wine awards and varietal shows like the Canberra International Riesling Challenge. In fact, over 100 in Australia alone.

    Then there is the Australian system of medals and trophies awarded out of 20 points. Only one trophy a year is awarded, making it a real winner. But medals are not like the Olympic gold, silver, bronze system. They are more like school grading - any wine that scores over the base line earns a gold, silver or bronze medal.

    So a bronze medal on a bottle of wine doesn't mean it's the third best wine in its category — it just means the judges found it drinkable.

    Classes are another thing. Shows can have hundreds of classes. Is a trophy for 'best shiraz under $10 class' worth more than a gold medal in the 'shiraz under $25' class? A double gold is when all judges agree the wine deserves a gold medal and the increasingly prevalent blue-gold medal indicates they judged the wine with food. This, to me, is the superior way to judge a wine!

    Just because a bottle has no medal, trophy or points doesn’t mean anything except it was never entered into a show. Judges at big shows taste hundreds of wines a day, so their palette could be muddied. 'Wine fatigue' means bigger, bolder wines are likely to win the top prizes - so if you're a fan of softer, more elegant wine, medal winners might not suit your taste.

    The American system —Australian judges, James Halliday and Huon Hooke prefer it - sees wine ranked out of 100. This is why you'll see many wines advertised as having been awarded scores of 95+.
    - Scores of 95 to 100 are highly recommended wines — 98 is fantastic
    -  99 and 100 are rare, but occasionally awarded to particularly good vintages
    - Anything above 90 is still classed as outstanding
    - 85 to 89 is very good
    - 80 to 84 creates your baseline for a good wine, which you’ll reach for again
    - 75 to 79 is the condescending 'drinkable' category
    - Everything below is generally not recommended

    While some wineries will put their scores out of 100 on the bottle, they most likely won't bother unless it was over 90. This may be a better indicator of a recommended wine than the medal system.

    With all this in mind Contentious Character has chosen a select group of medal and point-based awards to enter as a starting point for our award journey. James Halliday Wine Companion is the first to pass judgement on four of our wines.

    With scores of 90 plus for our 2016 Chardonnay, 2017 Riesling, 2016 Pinot Gris, and 89 points for our 2016 Pinot Noir, we’re feeling chuffed enough to make a fuss like all the others. The detailed notes are available in the 2019 Halliday Wine Companion, or by emailing us.

    Some of our Founders Museum wines (as far back as the 2001 vintage) won awards back in their heyday. I’ve noted with interest some awarded wines are still drinking exceptionally well so perhaps there is something in the awards business after all. Is that a little itch I feel down around my anus?

Popular Posts
  • Contentious Scores with Halliday
    A fellow vigneron and old friend of mine, who happens... 2018-09-08
  • Mulling over Mulled White Wine
    The Ancient Greeks weren’t really the type of people to leave extra... 2018-06-29
  • The Chinese love Australian wine
    For the first time ever, Australia is selling more wine... 2018-05-15
  • Merlot: the little blackbird
    Merlot is like the shy girl at a party. She... 2018-03-20
  • Shiraz – Que syrah syrah
    Oscar Wilde said (and we cheat a bit) wine is... 2018-02-06